Comparison to Other Nations

The United States has the potential to substantially improve its population’s health in the future.  The Commonwealth Fund, on their first national scorecard, indicated, “The United States would have to improve its performance on key indicators by 50 percent or more to reach benchmark rates.”[1] 

No comparable index to this study compares the United States to other nations, but individual measures do show what other countries have already achieved and indicate the potential for the United States.  For example, infant mortality rates in 35 countries are less than or equal to the rate in the United States (Table 10). The goal for the United States, as established by Healthy People 2010, is 4.5 deaths per 1,000 live births, an aggressive target that requires substantial improvement from current rates in the next four years.

Table 10 - Infant Mortality Rate, 2004[1]

Country

Rate

Iceland

2

Singapore

2

Finland

3

Japan

3

Monaco

3

Norway

3

San Marino

3

Sweden

3

Belgium

4

Cyprus

4

Czech Republic

4

Denmark

4

France

4

Germany

4

Greece

4

Italy

4

Netherlands

4

Portugal

4

Slovenia

4

Spain

4

Switzerland

4

Australia

5

Austria

5

Canada

5

Ireland

5

Israel

5

Luxembourg

5

Malta

5

New Zealand

5

Republic of Korea

5

United Kingdom

5

Andorra

6

Croatia

6

Cuba

6

Estonia

6

United States of America

6


Another broader measure used to compare health in countries is Healthy Life Expectancy.  This is the basic indicator of population health used by the World Health Organization and published each year in The World Health Report.  This indicator measures the equivalent number of years in full health that a newborn child can expect to live based on current death rates and current rates of illness and disability.  Improvement in healthy life expectancy is also the first goal of Healthy People 2010 for the United States.  Today, 27 countries have healthy life expectancies for males and females that exceed the United States (Table 11).  The highest, Japan, substantially exceeds the United States where a newborn baby girl can expect to have seven additional years and a newborn baby boy can expect to have five additional years in which to enjoy a healthy, active life.

Table 11 - Healthy Life Expectancy at Birth, 2002[3]

 Country

Female

Male

Japan

78

72

San Marino

76

71

Spain

75

70

Switzerland

75

71

Monaco

75

71

Sweden

75

72

France

75

69

Italy

75

71

Andorra

75

70

Australia

74

71

Canada

74

70

Germany

74

70

Luxembourg

74

69

Iceland

74

72

Norway

74

70

Austria

74

69

Finland

74

69

Belgium

73

69

Greece

73

69

Malta

73

70

Netherlands

73

70

Israel

72

70

Slovenia

72

67

New Zealand

72

69

United Kingdom

72

69

Portugal

72

67

Ireland

72

68

Singapore

71

69

United States of America

71

67

Denmark

71

69

Czech Republic

71

66

Republic of Korea

71

65

Cuba

70

67

Cyprus

68

67

Kuwait

67

67

While the United States does have some of the most advance technical medical care available, the use of electronic medical records by physicians is estimated at 17 percent.  Of nineteen studies, the top three countries averaged 80 percent use of electronic medical records by physicians1.


[1] Schoen, Cathy et. al. U.S. Health System Performance: A National Scorecard, Health Affairs, Sept 20, 2006, http://content.healthaffairs.org/cgi/content/abstract/hlthaff.25.w457

[2] World Health Organization, Core Health Indicators, http://www3.who.int/whosis/core/core_select.cfm

[3] World Health Organization, The World Health Report, 2006